For only the fourth time this season, the San Jose Sharks managed to scrape by with another regulation win last night. With a 4-3 win over the Seattle Kraken, the Sharks added the eleventh win of the season, but only the fourth that was won within 60 minutes of play, to their record. However, defenseman Michael Kesselring and forward Collin Graf were noticeably missing from the lineup…and not due to injury.
It’s clear Head Coach, Ryan Warsofsky, has completely lost the locker room less than 30 games into the season. About 10 games ago the team called a players-only meeting following a particularly tough loss (which reflects very poorly on Warsofsky’s grasp on the room). In a nonsense power-grab that has left many people scratching their heads, Warsofsky decided to make Kesselring and Graf healthy scratches. Obviously Warsofsky is trying to send a message…however that message is incredibly confusing and convoluted.
For starters, Kesselring hasn’t really actually done anything to warrant being a healthy scratch. If anything, he’s been pretty solid throughout the entire season so far. Kesselring himself is also confused by the decision to scratch him, saying he believes he’s coming off the ten best games of his career. Plus, he’s been noticeably effective off the puck. He is particularly good at taking the puck off the sticks of opponents, sitting in the 93rd percentile for takeaways in the entire league. This skill is especially valuable when you consider the Sharks’ defensemen have been lacking in that category, but excelling (unfortunately) in giveaways. Also, something about him makes opponents want to come after him. This frequently results in him forcing them to take a penalty, putting the Sharks on the powerplay.
However, Warsofsky is trying to force Kesselring into something he’s not. His entire career he’s been an offensive defenseman. This is not only echoed by Kesselring himself, but also very obvious just looking at his career statistics. We brought him in knowing he was very offensive minded, so why is Warsofsky trying to make him into a more stay-at-home defenseman? Especially when Dmitry Orlov, who has been on a shocking generational run of offensive production (while failing miserably defensively), is frequently responsible for goals against.
If Warsofsky is telling the offensive-minded Kesselring, who isn’t slaking defensively, he needs to focus on defense then why is he not telling the same to Orlov, who is actively hurting the team? Orlov’s offensive contributions very frequently cloud the judgement on his complete lack of defensive abilities. Last night he had three assists, so you’d think he was a +3 right? Nope! Although he assisted on three goals, he was also on the ice for all three of the Kraken’s goals resulting in a +/- of 0. Also, why hasn’t Darnell Nurse received an ounce of criticism? His supporters touted his poke-checking abilities, yet he has 32 giveaways and only 5 takeaways…so he’s not even doing the one thing expected of him.
Graf is a bit of a different story. Last season he was spectacular, so this season has been a bit disappointing for him. However, all of the blame shouldn’t be placed on him (looking at you Warsofsky). He has frequently been placed in positions he doesn’t belong, and doesn’t tend to stay in one spot for very long. Putting him out of position and not giving him enough time to adjust is not doing him any favors. There’s also a clear disconnect between him and Warsofsky, with him being visibly angry about being scratched and claiming he doesn’t believe Warsofsky is actually trying to motivate him by saying things like he “doesn’t care if he (Graf) doesn’t score another goal for the rest of the season”. The message of scratching Graf is made all the more confusing when you consider Warsofsky praised his development not too long ago. What’s even more confusing is the constant insistence on Mason Marchment and Ty Dellandrea. Both of those guys have been given golden opportunities, and failed spectacularly. Yet they never seem to face any consequences or criticism.
Another regulation win is great, but there are still looming issues with the coaching staff. There seems to be bubbling animosity forming between staff and players, and Warsofsky has completely lost control. That being said, was his control ever the right fit to begin with? If it was then, it definitely isn’t now. It shouldn’t have taken the coaching staff 25 games to realize pucks go into the net when they’re brought there deliberately, not by dumping into the zone. This can’t go on for much longer, and the players and fans alike deserve better.
