San Jose Sharks Make Puzzling Trade For Polak
The San Jose Sharks made their first move of the trade deadline and I’m not sure how to feel. On one hand the Sharks, like any team, could use more depth at both forward and defense. At the same time, I wonder if Roman Polak and Nick Spaling are the answer to this team’s problems.
More from Sharks News
- Norris Trophy odds show Erik Karlsson a step above the rest
- Red hot Couture provides a much needed boost
- Sharks return to SAP in sight
- Ryan Donato shines in his revenge game
- Tomas Hertl is off to a hot start
Initial Thoughts
Bad. Very bad. I don’t like this move at all. Polak and Spaling won’t push this team to the Stanley Cup Finals and this team has an expiring window. Looks like Doug Wilson wasted two second round picks on players that won’t provide their expected value.
If the Sharks are going for the championship this year, the opponents they will face are likely the Anaheim Ducks, Los Angeles Kings, Chicago Blackhawks and Washington Capitals in that order. Are the Sharks beating all of those teams in succession? No they are not so this trade doesn’t make sense to me.
I think San Jose could have found a Polak and Spaling on their farm team. Or at least very close to it.
— Travis Yost (@travisyost) February 22, 2016
Like, free tip here: San Jose isn't beating Anaheim or LA. Not sure I get the point of it.
— Travis Yost (@travisyost) February 22, 2016
If you're smart about a rebuild there really is no limit to how badly you can rip off teams trying to get past the first round.
— Steve “Dangle” Glynn (@Steve_Dangle) February 22, 2016
Remember when we called the Penguins stupid for giving up two 2nd round picks for Murray... Heh
— Jentry🏒🥅🚨 (@jalexander46) February 22, 2016
If we were excited about trading Douglas Murray for two second round picks, this trade is the inverse of that.
The Impact of Polak and Spaling
Since Polak was brought in to stabilize the third pairing, let’s look at how he compares to the other third-pairing defenseman on the Sharks, Brenden Dillon.
According to this chart which can be found here Polak produces much more offense on a much worse Toronto Maple Leafs team. However, Dillon is far superior at generating shots and goals as a defensive-oriented player. Dillon also looks like a competent NHL defenseman in every aspect that helps push play in the right direction. While Polak is somewhat better at suppressing shots and goals, the rest of his game isn’t NHL caliber. All Sharks fans can hope for is that the two defenseman can compliment each other.
As for Spaling, most fans will be happy if Pete DeBoer plays him over Mike Brown. So let’s see how the two players compare!
Well that is depressing.
If Brown is in fact the superior player at suppressing shots and goals, then why is Spaling in the NHL at all? While Spaling is an upgrade everywhere else, I don’t think I like the idea of a player that can’t exit the defensive zone. There is more to these players than HERO charts but if this is the case, the Sharks just traded two second round picks for replaceable depth players.
Next: Sharks Use Big First Period To Blow Past Blues
Looking at other sources doesn’t make things better. Polak and Spaling rank 21st and 22nd respectively in individual Corsi For/60 minutes. By shot generation standards, outside of Rich Clune the Maple Leafs scored two second round picks for their two worst players. Other than the fact that Polak gets lots of ice time, this trade should be discouraging in every fashion.
But if you want this to happen then you shouldn’t feel good with Polak getting any ice time at all.